Top SEO Metrics to Track in 2023 Now

Imagine pouring hours into your website’s content, optimizing every headline, nailing your keyword strategy—only to wonder: is any of it actually working? If that question hits a nerve, you’re not alone. For solopreneurs, freelancers, and agency leaders alike, SEO can feel like a black box—unless you know how to measure success. That’s where tracking the right SEO metrics comes in. In 2023, the digital landscape is shifting faster than ever, and the metrics you focus on can determine whether your strategy thrives or fizzles. In this post, we’ll unpack the essential SEO metrics to track in 2023, highlight tools to help you stay ahead, and arm you with actionable strategies to turn numbers into business growth.

Why Tracking SEO Metrics Matters

If you’ve ever felt lost in the whirlwind of SEO advice—bounce rates, backlinks, keyword rankings—you’re not alone. But here’s the truth: tracking SEO metrics isn’t just about geeky analytics. It’s about making smarter decisions that directly impact your business.

Why business owners often overlook SEO metrics

Many solopreneurs and startups get caught up in producing blog posts or launching PPC campaigns, assuming that traffic will just follow. But without tracking performance, how would you know:

• Which content actually drives leads?
• What keywords attract your ideal clients?
• Whether your SEO efforts are leading to conversions or just page views?

The real cost of NOT tracking your SEO metrics

Neglecting SEO metrics can lead to wasted resources, targeting the wrong audience, or worse—losing to competitors who are laser-focused on the right data. Without these insights, your strategies rely on assumptions instead of evidence.

Metrics reveal opportunities and weaknesses

Tracking allows you to identify pages with high bounce rates, optimize underperforming keywords, and double down on content that drives conversions. It transforms SEO from a guessing game into a strategic business function.

SEO metrics to track in 2023 are your compass

In 2023, Google’s algorithm continues to evolve with a stronger emphasis on user experience and topic authority. Metrics like Core Web Vitals, keyword intent alignment, and SERP visibility have become non-negotiable. Measuring these helps ensure your site is both visible and valuable to your users.

Bottom line? Without tracking the right SEO metrics, you’re flying blind. Data is no longer optional—it’s your clearest path to digital growth.

The Essential SEO Metrics in 2023

To compete in today’s ever-changing SEO landscape, you need to narrow your focus to the data points that truly matter. Here are the most important SEO metrics to track in 2023—each revealing specific insights about your organic strategy.

1. Organic Traffic

This is often your first signal that your SEO efforts are working. Use Google Analytics to track:

• Total organic sessions over time

Trends here give you a big picture of how visible your website is in unpaid search results.

2. Keyword Rankings

Monitoring the positions of your target keywords over time lets you know which content is rising or slipping. Do this weekly or monthly using tools like Ahrefs or SEMrush.

3. Click-Through Rate (CTR)

CTR shows how compelling your titles and meta descriptions are. A high impression but low CTR may mean your listing isn’t attracting enough clicks. Optimize for better metadata to improve this.

4. Bounce Rate & Dwell Time

These user engagement metrics tell you if visitors find your content useful. In 2023, Google increasingly rewards content that holds attention. A rapid bounce might signal outdated, thin, or misaligned content.

5. Core Web Vitals

This includes:

• Largest Contentful Paint (LCP)
• First Input Delay (FID)
• Cumulative Layout Shift (CLS)

These measure loading speed, interactivity, and visual stability—crucial for ranking and user experience.

6. Page Indexation

Make sure your important pages are indexed. Use Google Search Console to audit which URLs are indexed and identify crawl errors or coverage issues.

7. Backlink Profile

Quality backlinks are key to building domain authority. Monitor the quantity, quality, and anchor text of backlinks with SEO tools like Ahrefs or Moz.

8. Conversion Rate from Organic Traffic

Ultimately, traffic and engagement should lead to a goal—sign-ups, sales, or inquiries. This is arguably one of the most telling SEO metrics to track in 2023.

By keeping an eye on these metrics, you’ll gain a clear, quantifiable view of your SEO health and uncover areas ripe for improvement.

Tools to Monitor SEO & Analytics Effectively

Tracking SEO metrics to track in 2023 requires more than a spreadsheet and a hunch—you need the right tools that offer accuracy, automation, and insights. Let’s break down the most effective tools that simplify SEO monitoring for startups, agencies, and solopreneurs.

1. Google Search Console (Free)

Why it matters: This is your direct connection to Google’s perspective on your site. Key features include:

• Keyword performance (queries, clicks, impressions, CTR)
• Index coverage reports
• Page experience and Core Web Vitals insights

Use it weekly to catch and fix indexing issues, monitor rankings, and analyze trending queries.

2. Google Analytics (Free/GA4)

Why it matters: Google Analytics helps you understand how users engage with your content. Here’s what to watch:

• Organic traffic trends
• User behavior (bounce rate, session duration)
• Conversion tracking

GA4’s event-based model provides deeper insights into user interaction—essential for performance optimization in 2023.

3. Ahrefs & SEMrush (Paid)

Why they matter: Robust SEO suites like Ahrefs or SEMrush provide enterprise-level tracking. Use them to:

• Track keyword rankings automatically
• Audit backlinks and domain authority
• Analyze competitor SEO performance

For agencies and consultants, these tools are indispensable.

4. Screaming Frog (Free/Paid)

Why it matters: Screaming Frog is a website crawler that gives deep insight into technical SEO issues. Identify:

• Broken links and redirects
• Duplicate content
• Metadata errors

Use quarterly to maintain a technically sound website structure.

5. RankMath or Yoast for WordPress Users

Why it matters: If your site runs on WordPress, an SEO plugin simplifies on-page optimization. Features include:

• SEO scoring
• Schema markup
• Internal linking suggestions

These tools enhance how search engines read your pages, which affects how your SEO metrics evolve over time.

Choosing the right tools depends on your goals, size, and budget. But even a simple stack of Search Console + Analytics can give you tremendous clarity into how your site performs across all the SEO metrics to track in 2023.

Common SEO Pitfalls and How to Avoid Them

Even the most committed entrepreneurs fall into traps that derail their SEO progress. The good news? Most are preventable—especially when you track the right SEO metrics to track in 2023. Let’s uncover the most common SEO mistakes and how to course-correct.

1. Focusing Only on Rankings

The problem: Obsessing over keyword positions without factoring in CTR, relevance, or conversions.

Solution: Combine ranking data with user behavior metrics (like dwell time and CTR). Start optimizing for intent, not just volume.

2. Ignoring Mobile and Core Web Vitals

The problem: Overlooking the mobile experience and technical parameters can kill your rankings.

Solution: Run regular Core Web Vitals audits. Ensure your site is responsive, fast, and stable across all devices. Google’s PageSpeed Insights is a great place to start.

3. Not Adapting to Algorithm Updates

The problem: Using outdated keyword stuffing or backlink tactics post-2020.

Solution: Stay current with SEO best practices. In 2023, search engines prioritize relevance, helpfulness, and authority. Review Google updates quarterly and adjust strategies accordingly.

4. Tracking Vanity Metrics

The problem: Focusing on numbers that look good but have no business impact—like traffic without conversions.

Solution: Align SEO metrics closely with business goals. For example:

• Traffic → Leads → Sales pipeline
• Ranking → CTR → Goal conversions

This helps shift SEO from a marketing cost to a growth driver.

5. Infrequent SEO Audits

The problem: Set-it-and-forget-it SEO leads to issues festering undetected—like broken links, missing tags, or indexation errors.

Solution: Conduct quarterly SEO health checks. Automated tools (like SEMrush Site Audit or Screaming Frog) can automate this process and surface quick wins.

Awareness is half the battle. By avoiding these pitfalls—and constantly tracking the most relevant SEO metrics to track in 2023—you’ll move from reactive fixing to proactive scaling.

Actionable Steps to Improve Your SEO Metrics

Now that you know which SEO metrics to track in 2023 and which mistakes to avoid, let’s talk execution. What concrete actions can move the needle on your metrics this quarter? Here are six focused strategies:

1. Optimize Title Tags & Meta Descriptions

Why it works: Improving CTR improves both traffic and rankings. Use tools like Google Search Console to identify high-impression, low-CTR pages. Then A/B test new titles and descriptions with:

• Numbers & brackets (e.g., “Top 7 Strategies [2023 Update]”)
• Urgency (“Don’t Miss”) or solution-based language

2. Target Low-Hanging SEO Opportunities

Look for:

• Keywords where you’re ranking on page 2 (positions 11–20)
• Pages with backlinks but poor traffic

Updating content, adding internal links, or embedding videos often boosts these pages to page 1.

3. Enhance Content Depth & User Experience

Why it works: In-depth, value-packed content increases dwell time and shares. Use Google Analytics to see where users drop off, then:

• Add section summaries, tables of contents
• Include visuals, stats, expert quotes
• Answer People Also Ask queries in-line

4. Improve Site Speed and Mobile UX

Impact: Faster pages = better Core Web Vitals = higher rankings. Use these fixes:

• Compress images via TinyPNG or ShortPixel
• Use a CDN (like Cloudflare)
• Implement lazy loading and caching

5. Build Internal Links

Make every page work harder by interlinking related content. This improves crawlability and distributes authority more effectively. Use the “site:yourdomain.com ‘keyword’” trick to identify linking opportunities.

6. Track Conversions—not Just Clicks

Set up goals in GA4 that align with your business objectives, such as form fills, purchases, or calls. SEO success isn’t just traffic—it’s whether that traffic converts.

Improving SEO metrics to track in 2023 doesn’t require massive overhauls—it’s about consistent, informed tweaks. Measure your impact, test often, and keep refining based on the data.

Conclusion

The key takeaway? SEO isn’t just about getting found—it’s about being understood, trusted, and chosen. By focusing on the right SEO metrics to track in 2023, you’ll gain a sharper lens on what drives real value for your business. From keyword intent and page performance to conversion tracking and Core Web Vitals, every metric tells a story—and your job is to turn that story into strategy.

In a digital arena flooded with noise and ever-changing algorithms, tracking the right data points is your anchor. Whether you’re a solo founder or leading a multi-client agency, it’s time to stop guessing and start optimizing purposefully.

The road to SEO success isn’t mystical—it’s measurable. And you now have the map. So open your analytics, focus on what counts, and let the metrics reveal your next best move.

– As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Explore more on this topic